Thursday night at the Book Expo America convention
in Los Angeles, the Modern Library unveiled its list of the 100 best
nonfiction books of the 20th century.
Last August the Random House imprint suffered acute embarrassment after announcing its list of the 100 best fiction books: David Streitfeld of the Washington Post discovered that many members of the board that had done the choosing had no idea how the Modern Library had ranked the novels they had chosen. To spare itself and its board members any such humiliation this time around, the Modern Library took a tack that would make Descartes proud: It hired University of Chicago statistics professor Albert Madansky to do the rankings. "We knew we had to improve the process," Random House publisher Ann Godoff conceded at the ceremony last night. In addition to hiring Madansky, the Modern Library further livened up the existing board with two younger authors (Caleb Carr and Jon Krakauer), two additional women (Carolyn See and Elaine Pagels) and a black author (Charles Johnson).
The board met on two occasions to do the work of thinning the pool from 900 titles to 100. After board members ranked the books on a scale of zero to 10, Madansky ran the numbers through a computer program to come up with the ranking. Caleb Carr seemed pleased with the results: "I was shocked, especially in the top 20, at how balanced and how accurate the list was." According to Modern Library publisher David Ebershoff, there were no ties -- decimal points in Madansky's algorithms prevented them from happening. The list was restricted to books written in English. A rule that no author could have more than one book on the list eliminated Edmund Wilson's "To the Finland Station" and William James' "Pragmatism." Another rule stipulated that board members could not vote for their own books, but five members wound up being represented nonetheless: Shelby Foote, Stephen Jay Gould, Edmund Morris, Pagels and Arthur Schlesinger Jr.
Carolyn See felt it was high time for a West Coast woman like herself to sit on the board, which consisted mostly of East Coast scholars and historians. "On the one hand, I felt great; on the other hand, I felt like it was the 5 o'clock news and I was Sandra Hernandez Wong," See told Salon Books. "There were a lot of sports jackets in the room -- a lot of power and a lot of learnedness. I was unnerved. I hoped that I wouldn't spill my iced tea on Arthur Schlesinger."
In a hall full of literati and book vendors, the first choice, "The Education of Henry Adams," drew muted applause. Conversely, the fifth choice, "Silent Spring" by Rachel Carson, received hoots and whistles. Despite the promises of a perfect science, problems persist; some critics will certainly pick holes in the computations, others in the board members' choices. "One guy on the board whose name I won't mention started playing with his dentures," See reported. Now it's up to history to determine whether the list has any teeth.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
-
The Modern Library's list of the 100 best nonfiction books of the 20th century:
1. "THE EDUCATION OF HENRY ADAMS," Henry Adams
2. "THE VARIETIES OF RELIGIOUS EXPERIENCE," William James
3. "UP FROM SLAVERY," Booker T. Washington
4. "A ROOM OF ONE'S OWN," Virginia Woolf
5. "SILENT SPRING," Rachel Carson
6. "SELECTED ESSAYS, 1917-1932," T.S. Eliot
7. "THE DOUBLE HELIX," James D. Watson
8. "SPEAK, MEMORY," Vladimir Nabokov
9. "THE AMERICAN LANGUAGE," H.L. Mencken
10. "THE GENERAL THEORY OF EMPLOYMENT, INTEREST, AND MONEY," John Maynard Keynes
11. "THE LIVES OF A CELL," Lewis Thomas
12. "THE FRONTIER IN AMERICAN HISTORY," Frederick Jackson Turner
13. "BLACK BOY," Richard Wright
14. "ASPECTS OF THE NOVEL," E.M. Forster
15. "THE CIVIL WAR," Shelby Foote
16. "THE GUNS OF AUGUST," Barbara W. Tuchman
17. "THE PROPER STUDY OF MANKIND," Isaiah Berlin
18. "THE NATURE AND DESTINY OF MAN," Reinhold Niebuhr
19. "NOTES OF A NATIVE SON," James Baldwin
20. "THE AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF ALICE B. TOKLAS," Gertrude Stein
21. "THE ELEMENTS OF STYLE," William Strunk and E.B. White
22. "AN AMERICAN DILEMMA," Gunnar Myrdal
23. "PRINCIPIA MATHEMATICA," Alfred North Whitehead and Bertrand Russell
24. "THE MISMEASURE OF MAN," Stephen Jay Gould
25. "THE MIRROR AND THE LAMP," Meyer Howard Abrams
26. "THE ART OF THE SOLUBLE," Peter B. Medawar
27. "THE ANTS," Bert Hoelldobler and Edward O. Wilson
28. "A THEORY OF JUSTICE," John Rawls
29. "ART AND ILLUSION," Ernest H. Gombrich
30. "THE MAKING OF THE ENGLISH WORKING CLASS," E.P. Thompson
31. "THE SOULS OF BLACK FOLK," W.E.B. Du Bois
32. "PRINCIPIA ETHICA," G.E. Moore
33. "PHILOSOPHY AND CIVILIZATION," John Dewey
34. "ON GROWTH AND FORM," D'Arcy Wentworth Thompson
35. "IDEAS AND OPINIONS," Albert Einstein
36. "THE AGE OF JACKSON," Arthur M. Schlesinger Jr.
37. "THE MAKING OF THE ATOMIC BOMB," Richard Rhodes
38. "BLACK LAMB AND GREY FALCON," Rebecca West
39. "AUTOBIOGRAPHIES," W.B. Yeats
40. "SCIENCE AND CIVILIZATION IN CHINA," Joseph Needham
41. "GOODBYE TO ALL THAT," Robert Graves
42. "HOMAGE TO CATALONIA," George Orwell
43. "THE AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF MARK TWAIN," Mark Twain
44. "CHILDREN OF CRISIS," Robert Coles
45. "A STUDY OF HISTORY," Arnold J. Toynbee
46. "THE AFFLUENT SOCIETY," John Kenneth Galbraith
47. "PRESENT AT THE CREATION," Dean Acheson
48. "THE GREAT BRIDGE," David McCullough
49. "PATRIOTIC GORE," Edmund Wilson
50. "SAMUEL JOHNSON," Walter Jackson Bate
51. "THE AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF MALCOLM X," Alex Haley and Malcolm X
52. "THE RIGHT STUFF," Tom Wolfe
53. "EMINENT VICTORIANS," Lytton Strachey
54. "WORKING," Studs Terkel
55. "DARKNESS VISIBLE," William Styron
56. "THE LIBERAL IMAGINATION," Lionel Trilling
57. "THE SECOND WORLD WAR," Winston Churchill
58. "OUT OF AFRICA," Isak Dinesen
59. "JEFFERSON AND HIS TIMES," Dumas Malone
60. "IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN," William Carlos Williams
61. "CADILLAC DESERT," Marc Reisner
62. "THE HOUSE OF MORGAN," Ron Chernow
63. "THE SWEET SCIENCE," A. J. Liebling
64. "THE OPEN SOCIETY AND ITS ENEMIES," Karl Popper
65. "THE ART OF MEMORY," Frances A. Yates
66. "RELIGION AND THE RISE OF CAPITALISM," R. H. Tawney
67. "A PREFACE TO MORALS," Walter Lippmann
68. "THE GATE OF HEAVENLY PEACE," Jonathan D. Spence
69. "THE STRUCTURE OF SCIENTIFIC REVOLUTIONS," Thomas S. Kuhn
70. "THE STRANGE CAREER OF JIM CROW," C. Vann Woodward
71. "THE RISE OF THE WEST," William H. McNeill
72. "THE GNOSTIC GOSPELS," Elaine Pagels
73. "JAMES JOYCE," Richard Ellmann
74. "FLORENCE NIGHTINGALE," Cecil Woodham-Smith
75. "THE GREAT WAR AND MODERN MEMORY," Paul Fussell
76. "THE CITY IN HISTORY," Lewis Mumford
77. "BATTLE CRY OF FREEDOM," James M. McPherson
78. "WHY WE CAN'T WAIT," Martin Luther King Jr.
79. "THE RISE OF THEODORE ROOSEVELT," Edmund Morris
80. "STUDIES IN ICONOLOGY," Erwin Panofsky
81. "THE FACE OF BATTLE," John Keegan
82. "THE STRANGE DEATH OF LIBERAL ENGLAND," George Dangerfield
83. "VERMEER," Lawrence Gowing
84. "A BRIGHT SHINING LIE," Neil Sheehan
85. "WEST WITH THE NIGHT," Beryl Markham
86. "THIS BOY'S LIFE," Tobias Wolff
87. "A MATHEMATICIAN'S APOLOGY," G.H. Hardy
88. "SIX EASY PIECES," Richard P. Feynman
89. "PILGRIM AT TINKER CREEK," Annie Dillard
90. "THE GOLDEN BOUGH," James George Frazer
91. "SHADOW AND ACT," Ralph Ellison
92. "THE POWER BROKER," Robert A. Caro
93. "THE AMERICAN POLITICAL TRADITION," Richard Hofstadter
94. "THE CONTOURS OF AMERICAN HISTORY," William Appleman Williams
95. "THE PROMISE OF AMERICAN LIFE," Herbert Croly
96. "IN COLD BLOOD," Truman Capote
97. "THE JOURNALIST AND THE MURDERER," Janet Malcolm
98. "THE TAMING OF CHANCE," Ian Hacking
99. "OPERATING INSTRUCTIONS," Anne Lamott
100. "MELBOURNE," Lord David Cecil
Shares